Prepared by David Reed email@example.com or firstname.lastname@example.org
The Last Stetson
by John Fox Jr.
A MIDSUMMER freshet was running over old Gabe Bunch's
water-wheel into the Cumberland. Inside the mill Steve Marcum
lay in one dark corner with a slouched hat over his face. The boy
Isom was emptying a sack of corn into the hopper. Old Gabe was
speaking his mind.
Always the miller had been a man of peace; and there was one
time when he thought the old Stetson-Lewallen feud was done.
That was when Rome Stetson, the last but one of his name, and
Jasper Lewallen, the last but one of his, put their guns down and
fought with bare fists on a high ledge above old Gabe's mill one
morning at daybreak. The man who was beaten was to leave the
mountains; the other was to stay at home and have peace. Steve
Marcum, a Stetson, heard the sworn terms and saw the fight.
Jasper was fairly whipped; and when Rome let him up he proved
treacherous and ran for his gun. Rome ran too, but stumbled and
fell. Jasper whirled with his Winchester and was about to kill
Rome where he lay, when a bullet came from somewhere and
dropped him back to the ledge again. Both Steve Marcum and
Rome Stetson said they had not fired the shot; neither would say
who had. Some thought one man was lying, some thought the
other was, and Jasper's death lay between the two. State troops
came then, under the Governor 's order, from the Blue Grass, and
Rome had to drift down the river one night in old Gabe's canoe and
on Out of the mountains for good. Martha Lewallen, who, though
Jasper's sister, and the last of the name, loved and believed Rome,
went with him. Marcums and Braytons who had taken sides in the
fight hid in the bushes around Hazlan, or climbed over into
Virginia. A railroad started up the Cumberland. "Furriners came
in to buy wild lands and get out timber. Civilization began to press
over the mountains and down on Hazlan, as it had pressed in on
Breathitt, the seat of another feud, in another county. In Breathitt
the feud was long past, and with good reason old Gabe thought
that it was done in Hazlan.
But that autumn a panic started over from England. It stopped the
railroad far down the Cumberland; it sent the "furriners" home,
and drove civilization back. Marcums and Braytons came in from
hiding, and drifted one by one to the old fighting-ground. In time
they took up the old quarrel, and with Steve Marcum and Steve
Brayton as leaders, the old Stetson-Lewallen feud went on, though
but one soul was left in the mountains of either name. That was
Isom, a pale little fellow whom Rome had left in old Gabe's care;
and he, though a Stetson and a half-brother to Rome, was not
counted, because he was only a boy and a foundling, and because
his ways were queer.
There was no open rupture, no organized division-that might
happen no more. The mischief was individual now, and
ambushing was more common. Certain men were looking for
each other, and it was a question of "draw-in' quick 'n' shootin'
quick" when the two met by accident, or of getting the advantage
"from the bresh."
In time Steve Marcum had come face to face with old Steve
Brayton in Hazlan, and the two Steves, as they were known, drew
promptly. Marcum was in the dust when the smoke cleared away;
and now, after three months in bed, he was just out again. He had
come down to the mill to see Isom. This was the miller's first
chance for remonstrance, and, as usual, he began to lay it down
that every man who had taken a human life must sooner or later
pay for it with his own. It was an old story to Isom, and, with a
shake of impatience, he turned out the door of the mill, and left old
Gabe droning on under his dusty hat to Steve, who, being heavy
with "moonshine," dropped asleep.
Outside the sun was warm, the flood was calling from the dam,
and the boy's petulance was gone at once. For a moment he stood
on the rude platform watching the tide; then he let one bare foot
into the water, and, with a shiver of delight, dropped from the
boards. In a moment his clothes were on the ground behind a
laurel thicket, and his slim white body was flashing like a faun
through the reeds and bushes up stream. A hundred yards away
the creek made a great loop about a wet thicket of pine and
rhododendron, and he turned across the bushy neck. Creeping
through the gnarled bodies of rhododendron, he dropped suddenly
behind the pine, and lay flat in the black earth. Ten yards through
the dusk before him was the half-bent figure of a man letting an
old army haversack slip from one shoulder; and Isom watched him
hide it with a rifle under a bush, and go noiselessly on towards the
road. It was Crump, Eli Crump, who had been a spy for the
Lewallens in the old feud and who was spying now for old Steve
Brayton. It was the second time Isom had seen him lurking about,
and the boy's impulse was to hurry back to the mill. But it was still
peace, and without his gun Crump was not dangerous; so Isom
rose and ran on, and, splashing into the angry little stream, shot
away like a roll of birch bark through the tawny crest of a big
wave. He had done the feat a hundred times; he knew every rock
and eddy in flood-time, and he floated through them and slipped
like an eel into the mill-pond. Old Gabe was waiting for him.
"Whut ye mean, boy," he said, sharply, reskin' the fever an' ager
this way? No wonder folks thinks ye air half crazy. Git inter them
clothes now 'n' come in hyeh. You'll ketch yer death o' cold
swimmin' this way atter a fresh."
The boy was shivering when he took his seat at the funnel, but he
did not mind that; some day he meant to swim over that dam.
Steve still lay motionless in the corner near him, and Isom lifted
the slouched hat and began tickling his lips with a straw. Steve
was beyond the point of tickling, and Isom dropped the hat back
and turned to tell the miller what he had seen in the thicket. The
dim interior darkened just then, and Crump stood in the door. Old
Gabe stared hard at him without a word of welcome, but Crump
shuffled to a chair unasked, and sat like a toad astride it, with his
knees close up under his arms, and his wizened face in his hands.
Meeting Isom's angry glance, he shifted his own uneasily.
Seed the new preacher comm' 'long today?" he asked. Drawing
one dirty finger across his forehead, " Got a long scar 'cross hyeh."
The miller shook his head.
Well, he's a-comm'. I've been waitin' fer him up the road, but I
reckon I got to git 'cross the river purty soon now."
Crump had been living over in Breathitt since the old feud. He
had been "convicted" over there by Sherd Raines, a preacher from
the Jellico Hills, and he had grown pious. Indeed, he had been
trailing after Raines from place to place, and he was following the
circuit-rider now to the scene of his own deviltry-Hazlan.
"Reckon you folks don't know I got the cirkit-rider to come over
hyeh, do ye?" he went on. "Ef he can't preach! Well, I'd tell a
man! He kin jus' draw the heart out'n a holler log! He ' convicted '
me fust night, over thar in Breathitt. He come up thar, ye know, to
stop the feud, he said; 'n' thar was laughin' from one eendo'
Breathitt to t'other; but thar was the whoppinest crowd thar I ever
see when he did come. The meetin'-house wasn't big enough to
hold 'em, so he goes out on the aidge o' town, n' climbs on to a
stump. He hed a woman with him from the settlemints-she's
a-waitin' at Hazlan fer him now-'n' she had a cur'us little box, 'n' he
put her 'n' the box on a big rock, 'n' started in a callin' 'em his
bretherin' 'n' sisteren, 'n' folks seed mighty soon thet he meant it,
too. He's always mighty easylike, tell he gits to the blood-penalty."
At the word, Crump's listeners paid sudden heed. Old Gabe's knife
stopped short in the heart of the stick he was whittling; the boy
looked sharply up from the running meal into Crump's face and sat
Well, he jes prayed to the Almighty as though he was a-talkin' to
him face to face, 'n' then the woman put her hands on that box, 'n'
the sweetes' sound anybody thar ever heerd come outen it. Then
she got to singin'. Hit wusn't nuthin' anybody thar'd ever heerd; but
some o' the women folks was a snifflin' 'fore she got through. He
pitched right into the feud, as he calls hit, 'n' the sin o' sheddin'
human blood, I tell ye; 'n' 'twixt him and the soldiers I reckon thar
won't be no more fightin' in Breathitt. He says, 'n' he always says it
mighty loud "-Crump raised his own voice-" thet the man as kills
his feller-critter hev some day got ter give up his own blood, sartin
It was old Gabe's pet theory, and he was nodding approval. The
boy's parted lips shook with a spasm of fear, and were as quickly
shut tight with suspicion. Steve raised his head as though he too
had heard the voice, and looked stupidly about him.
I tol' him," Crump went on, " thet things was already a-gettin' kind
o' frolicsome round hyeh agin; thet the Marcums 'n' Braytons was
a-takin' up the ole war, 'n' would be a-plunkin' one 'nother every
time they got together, 'n' a-gittin' the whole country in fear 'n'
tremblin' -now thet Steve Marcum had come back."
Steve began to scowl and a vixenish smile hovered at Isom's lips.
He knows mighty well-fer I tol' him-thet thar hain't a wuss man in
all these mountains than thet very Steve-" The name ended in a
gasp, and the wizened gossip was caught by the throat and tossed,
chair and all, into a corner of the mill.
None o' that, Steve! " called the miller, sternly. "Not hyeh. Don't
hurt him now!
Crump's face stiffened with such terror that Steve broke into a
Well, ye air a skeery critter! " he said, contemptuously. "I hain't
goin' to hurt him, Uncl' Gabe, but he must be a plumb idgit,
a-talkin' 'bout folks to thar face, 'n' him so puny an' spindlin'! You
Crump picked himself up trembling-"Don't ye ever let me see ye
on this side o' the river agin, now "-and shuffled out, giving
Marcum one look of fear and unearthly hate.
Convicted '! " snorted Steve. " I heerd old Steve Brayton had hired
him to waylay me, 'n' I swar I believe hit's so."
"Well, he won't hev to give him more'n a chaw o' tobaccer now,"
said Gabe. " He'll come purty near doin' hit hisseif, I reckon, ef he
gits the chance."
Well, he kin git the chance ef I gits my leetle account settled with
ole Steve Brayton fust. 'Pears like that old hog ain't satisfied
shootin' me hisself." Stretching his arms with a yawn, Steve
winked at Isom and moved to the door. The boy followed him
"We're goin' fer ole Brayton about the dark o' the next moon, boy,"
he said. "He's sort o' s'picious now, 'n' we'll give him a leetle time
to git tame. I'll have a bran'-new Winchester fer ye, Isom. Hit ull
be like ole times agin, when Rome was hyeh. Whut's the matter,
boy?" he asked, suddenly. Isom looked unresponsive, listless.
Air ye gittin' sick agin?
Well, I hain't feelin' much peert, Steve."
Take keer o' yourself, boy. Don't git sick now. We'll have to
watch Eli Crump purty close. I don't know why I hain't killed thet
spyin' skunk long ago, 'ceptin' I never had a shore an' sartin reason
fer doin 'it.
Isom started to speak then and stopped. He would learn more first;
and he let Steve go on home unwarned.
The two kept silence after Marcum had gone. Isom turned away
from old Gabe, and stretched himself out on the platform. He
looked troubled. The miller, too, was worried.
Jus' a hole in the groun'," he said, half to himself; "that's whut
we're all comm' to! 'Pears like we mought help one 'nother to keep
out'n hit, 'stid o' holpin' 'em in."
Brown shadows were interlacing out in the mill-pond, where old
Gabe's eyes were intent. A current of cool air had started down the
creek to the river. A katydid began to chant. Twilight was
coming, and the miller rose.
"Hit's a comfort to know you won't be mixed up in all this
devilment," he said; and then, as though he had found more light in
the gloom: "Hit's a comfort to know the new rider air shorely
a-preachin' the right doctrine, 'n' I want ye to go hear him. Blood
for blood-life fer a life! Your grandad shot ole Tom Lewallen in
Hazlan. Ole Jack Lewallen shot him from the bresh. Tom Stetson
killed ole Jack; ole Jass killed Tom, 'n' so hit comes down, fer back
as I can ricollect. I hev nuver knowed hit to fail." The lad had
risen on one elbow. His face was pale and uneasy, and he averted
it when the miller turned in the door.
"You'd better stay hyeh, son, 'n' finish up the grist. Hit won't take
long. Hev ye got victuals fer yer supper?
Isom nodded, without looking around, and when old Gabe was
gone he rose nervously and dropped helplessly back to the floor.
"'Pears like old Gabe knows I killed Jass," he breathed, sullenly.
'Pears like all of 'em knows hit, 'n' air jus' a-tormentin' me."
Nobody dreamed that the boy and his old gun had ended that fight
on the cliff; and without knowing it, old Gabe kept the lad in
constant torture with his talk of the blood-penalty. But Isom got
used to it in time, for he had shot to save his brother's life. Steve
Marcum treated him thereafter as an equal. Steve's friends, too,
changed in manner towards him because Steve had. And now, just
when he had reached the point of wondering whether, after all,
there might not be one thing that old Gabe did not know, Crump
had come along with the miller's story, which he had got from still
another, a circuit-rider, who must know the truth. The fact gave
"Mebbe hit's goin' to happen when I goes with Steve atter ole
Brayton," he mumbled, and he sat thinking the matter over, until a
rattle and a whir inside the mill told him that the hopper was
empty. He arose to fill it, and coming out again, he heard
hoof-beats on the dirt road. A stranger rode around the
rhododendrons and shouted to him, asking the distance to Hazlan.
He took off his hat when Isom answered, to wipe the dust and
perspiration from his face, and the boy saw a white scar across his
forehead. A little awestricken, the lad walked towards him.
"Air you the new rider whut's goin' to preach up to Hazlan? " he
Raines smiled at the solemnity of the little fellow. " Yes," he said,
kindly. " Won't you come up and hear me?"
"Yes, sir," he said, and his lips parted as though he wanted to say
something else, but Raines did not notice.
"I wished I had axed him," he said, watching the preacher ride
away. " Uncle Gabe knows might' nigh ever'thing, 'n' he says so.
Crump said the rider said so; but Crump might 'a' been lyin'. He
'most al'ays is. I wished I had axed him."
Mechanically the lad walked along the millrace, which was made
of hewn boards and hollow logs. In every crevice grass hung in
thick bunches to the ground or tipped wiry blades over the running
water. Tightening a prop where some silvery jet was getting too
large, he lifted the tail-gate a trifle and lay down again on the
platform near the old wheel. Out in the mill-pond the water would
break now and then into ripples about some unwary moth, and the
white belly of a fish would flash from the surface. It was the only
sharp accent on the air. The chant of the katydids had become a
chorus, and the hush of darkness was settling over the steady flow
of water and the low drone of the millstones.
"I hain't afeerd," he kept saying to himself. "I hain't afeerd o'
nothin' nor no-body; but he lay brooding until his head throbbed,
until darkness filled the narrow gorge, and the strip of dark blue up
through the trees was pointed with faint stars. He was troubled
when he rose, and climbed on Rome's horse and rode homeward
-so troubled that he turned finally and started back in a gallop for
It was almost as Crump had said. There was no church in Hazlan,
and, as in Breathitt, the people had to follow Raines outside the
town, and he preached from the roadside. The rider's Master never
had a tabernacle more simple: overhead the stars and a low moon;
close about, the trees still and heavy with summer; a pine torch
over his head like a yellow plume; two tallow dips hung to a beech
on one side, and flicking to the other the shadows of the people
who sat under them. A few Marcums and Braytons were there,
one faction shadowed on Raines's right, one on his left. Between
them the rider stood straight, and prayed as though talking with
some one among the stars. Behind him the voice of the woman at
her tiny organ rose among the leaves. And then he spoke as he had
prayed; and from the first they listened like children, while in their
own homely speech he went on to tell them, just as he would have
told children, a story that some of them had never heard before.
"Forgive your enemies as He had forgiven his," that was his plea.
Marcums and Braytons began to press in from the darkness on
each side, forgetting each other as the rest of the people forgot
them. And when the story was quite done, Raines stood a full
minute without a word. No one was prepared for what followed.
Abruptly his voice rose sternly-" Thou shalt not kill" ; and then
Satan took shape under the torch. The man was transformed,
swaying half crouched before them. The long black hair fell across
the white scar, and picture after picture leaped from his tongue
with such vividness that a low wail started through the audience,
and women sobbed in their bonnets. It was penalty for bloodshed
-not in this world: penalty eternal in the next; and one slight figure
under the dips staggered suddenly aside into the darkness.
It was Isom; and no soul possessed of devils was ever more torn
than his, when he splashed through Troubled Fork and rode away
that night. Half a mile on he tried to keep his eyes on his horse's
neck, anywhere except on one high gray rock to which they were
raised against his will-the peak under which he had killed young
Jasper. There it was staring into the moon, but watching him as
he fled through the woods, shuddering at shadows, dodging
branches that caught at him as he passed, and on in a run, until he
drew rein and slipped from his saddle at the friendly old mill.
There was no terror for him there. There every bush was a friend;
every beech trunk a sentinel on guard for him in shining armor.
It was the old struggle that he was starting through that night-the
old fight of humanity from savage to Christian; and the lad fought
it until, with the birth of his wavering soul, the premonitions of the
first dawn came on. The patches of moonlight shifted, paling.
The beech columns mottled slowly with gray and brown. A ruddy
streak was cleaving the east like a slow sword of fire. The chill air
began to pulse and the mists to stir. Moisture had gathered on the
boy's sleeve. His horse was stamping uneasily, and the lad rose
stiffly, his face gray but calm, and started home. At old Gabe's
gate he turned in his saddle to look where, under the last sinking
star, was once the home of his old enemies. Farther down, under
the crest, was old Steve Brayton, alive, and at that moment perhaps
"Forgive your enemies;" that was the rider's plea. Forgive old
Steve, who had mocked him, and had driven Rome from the
mountains; who had threatened old Gabe's life,. and had shot Steve
Marcum almost to death! The lad drew breath quickly, and
standing in his stirrups, stretched out his fist, and let it drop,
OLD Gabe was just starting out when Isom' reached the cabin, and
the old man thought the boy had been at the mill all night. Isom
slept through the day, and spoke hardly a word when the miller
came home, though the latter had much to say of Raines, the two
Steves, and of the trouble possible. He gave some excuse for not
going with old Gabe the next day, and instead went into the woods
Late in the middle of the afternoon he reached the mill. Old Gabe
sat smoking outside the door, and Isom stretched himself out on
the platform close to the water, shading his eyes from the rich
sunlight with one ragged sleeve.
"Uncl' Gabe," he said, suddenly, " s'posin' Steve Brayton was to
step out'n the bushes thar some mawnin' 'n' pull down his
Winchester on ye, would ye say, ' Lawd, fergive him, fer he don't
know whut he do'?"
Old Gabe had told him once about a Stetson and a Lewallen who
were heard half a mile away praying while they fought each other
to death with Winchesters. There was no use prayin' an' shootin',"
the miller declared. There was but one way for them to escape
damnation; that was to throw down their guns and make friends.
But the miller had forgotten, and his mood that morning was
Well, I mought, Isom," he said, " ef I didn't happen to have a gun
The humor was lost on Isom. His chin was moving up and down,
and his face was serious. That was just it. He could forgive
Jass-Jass was dead; he could forgive Crump, if he caught him in no
devilment; old Brayton even-after Steve's revenge was done. But
now- The boy rose, shaking his head.
Uncl' Gabe," he said with sudden passion, "whut ye reckon Rome's
The miller looked a little petulant. " Don't ye git tired axin' me
thet question, Isom? Rome's a-scratchin' right peert fer a livin', I
reckon, fer hisself 'n' Marthy. Yes, 'n' mebbe fer a young 'un too by
this time. Ef ye air honin' fer Rome, why don't ye rack out 'n' go to
him? Lawd knows I'd hate ter see ye go, but I tol' Rome I'd let ye
whenever ye got ready, 'n' so I will."
Isom had no answer, and old Gabe was puzzled. It was always this
way. The boy longed for Rome, the miller could see. He spoke of
him sometimes with tears, and sometimes he seemed to be on the
point of going to him, but he shrank inexplicably when the time for
Isom started into the mill now without a word, as usual. Old Gabe
noticed that his feet were unsteady, and with quick remorse began
to question him.
" Kinder puny, hain't ye, Isom?
" Well, I hain't feelin' much peert."
" Hit was mighty keerless," old Gabe said, with kindly reproach, "
swimmin' the crick atter a fresh."
Hit wasn't the swimmin'," he protested, dropping weakly at the
threshold. "Hit was settin' out n the woods. I was in Hazlan t'other
night, Und' Gabe, to hear the new rider."
The miller looked around with quick interest. "I've been skeered
afore by riders a-tellin' 'bout the torments o' hell, but I never heerd
nothin' like his tellin' 'bout the Lord. He said the Lord was jes as
pore as anybody thar, and lived jes as rough; thet He made fences
and barns n' ox-yokes 'n' sech like, an' He couldn't write His own
name when He started out to save the worl'; an' when he come to
the p'int whar His enemies tuk hol' of Him, the rider jes crossed his
fingers up over his head 'n' axed us if we didn't know how it hurt to
run a splinter into a feller's hand when he's loggin' or a thorn into
yer foot when ye're goin' barefooted.
Hit jes made me sick, Uncl' Gabe, hearin' him tell how they
stretched Him out on a cross o' wood, when He'd come down fer
nothin' but to save 'em, 'n' stuck a spear big as a co'n-knife into His
side, 'n' give Him vinegar, 'n' let Him hang thar 'n' die, with His
own mammy a-stand-in' down on the groun' a-cryin' 'n' watchin'
Him. Some folks thar never heerd sech afore. The women was
a-rockin', 'n' ole Granny Day axed right out ef thet tuk place a long
time ago; 'n' the rider said, 'Yes, a long time ago, mos two
thousand years.' Granny was a-cryin', Uncl' Gabe, 'n' she said,
sorter soft, ' Stranger, let's hope that hit hain't so ' ; 'n' the rider
says, But hit air so; n' He fergive em while they was doin' it.'
Thet's whut got me, Uncl' Gabe, 'n' when the woman got to singin',
somethin' kinder broke loose hyeh "-Isom passed his hand over his
thin chest-" 'n' I couldn't git breath. I was mos' afeerd to ride home.
I jes layed at the mill studyin', till I thought my head would bust. I
reckon hit was the spent a-work-in me. Looks like I was mos'
convicted, Uncl' Gabe." His voice trembled and he stopped.
Crump was a-lyin'," he cried, suddenly. "But hit's wuss, Und' Gabe;
hit's wuss! You say a life fer a life in this worl'; the rider says hit's
in the next, 'n' I'm mis'ble, Uncl' Gabe. Ef Rome-I wish Rome was
hyeh," he cried, helplessly. "I don't know whut to do."
The miller rose and limped within the mill, and ran one hand
through the shifting corn. He stood in the doorway, looking long
and perplexedly towards Hazlan; he finally saw, he thought, just
what the lad's trouble was. He could give him some comfort, and
he got his chair and dragged it out to the door across the platform,
and sat down in silence.
Isom," he said at last, "the Spent air shorely a-workin' ye, 'n' I'm
glad of it. But ye mus 'n t worry about the penalty a-fallin' on
Rome. Steve Marcum killed Jass-he can't fool me-'n' I've told
Steve he's got thet penalty to pay ef he gits up this trouble. I'm
glad the Spent's a-workin' ye, but ye mus'n' t worry 'bout Rome."
Isom rose suddenly on one elbow, and with a moan lay back and
crossed his arms over his face.
Old Gabe turned and left him.
Git up, Isom." It was the miller's voice again, an hour later. "You
better go home now. Ride the hoss, boy," he and, kindly.
Isom rose, and old Gabe helped him mount, and stood at the door.
The horse started, but the boy pulled him to a standstill again.
"I want to ax ye jes one thing more, Uncl' Gabe," he said, slowly."
S'posin' Steve had a-killed Jass to keep him from killin' Rome, hev
he got to be damned fer it jes the same? Hev he got to give up
eternal life anyways? Hain't thar no way out'n it-no way?"
There was need for close distinction now and the miller was
Ef Steve shot Jass," he said, " jes to save Rome's life-he had the
right to shoot him. Thar hain't no doubt 'bout that. The law says
so. But "-there was a judicial pause-"I've heerd Steve say that he
hated Jass wuss' n anybody on earth, 'cept old Brayton; 'n' ef he
wus glad o' the chance o' killin' him, why-the Lord air merciful,
Isom; the Bible air true, 'n' hit says an ' eye fer an eye, a tooth fer a
tooth,' 'n' I never knowed hit to fail-but the Lord air merciful. Ef
Steve would only jes repent, 'n' ef, 'stid o' fightin' the Lord by takin'
human life, he'd fight fer Him by savin' it, I reckon the Lord would
fergive him. Fer ef ye lose yer life fer Him, He do say you'll find it
Old Gabe did not see the sullen despair that came into the boy's
tense face. The subtlety of the answer had taken the old man back
to the days when he was magistrate, and his eyes were half closed.
Isom rode away without a word. From the dark of the mill old
Gabe turned to look after him again.
"I'm afeerd he's a-gittin' feverish agin. Hit looks like he's
convicted; but "-he knew the wavering nature of the boy-" I don't
know-I don't know."
Going home an hour later, the old man saw several mountaineers
climbing the path towards Steve Marcum's cabin; it meant the
brewing of mischief; and when he stopped at his own gate, he saw
at the bend of the road a figure creep from the bushes on one side
into the bushes on the other.
It looked like Crump.
IT was Crump, and fifty yards behind him was Isom, slipping
through the brush after him -Isom's evil spirit-old Gabe, Raines, "
conviction," blood-penalty, forgotten, all lost in the passion of a
chase which has no parallel when the game is man.
Straight up the ravine Crump went along a path which led to Steve
Marcum's cabin. There was a clump of rhododendron at the head
of the ravine, and near Steve's cabin. About this hour Marcum
would be chopping wood for supper, or sitting out in his porch in
easy range from the thicket. Crump's plan was plain: he was about
his revenge early, and Isom was exultant.
"Oh, no, Eli, you won't git Steve this time. Oh, naw!
The bushes were soon so thick that he could no longer follow
Crump by sight, and every few yards he had to stop to listen, and
then steal on like a mountain-cat towards the leaves rustling ahead
of him. Half-way up the ravine Crump turned to the right and
stopped. Puzzled, Isom pushed so close that the spy, standing
irresolute on the edge of the path, whirled around. The boy
sank to his face, and in a moment footsteps started and grew faint;
Crump had darted across the path, and was running through the
undergrowth up the spur. Isom rose and hurried after him; and
when, panting hard, he reached the top, the spy's skulking figure
was sliding from Steve's house and towards the Breathitt road; and
with a hot, puzzled face, the boy went down after it.
On a little knob just over a sudden turn in the road Crump stopped,
and looking sharply about him, laid his gun down. Just in front of
him were two rocks, waist-high, with a crevice between them.
Drawing a long knife from his pocket, he climbed upon them, and
began to cut carefully away the spreading top of a bush that grew
on the other side. Isom crawled down towards him like a lizard,
from tree to tree. A moment later the spy was filling up the
crevice with stones, and Isom knew what he was about; he was
making a "blind" to waylay Steve, who, the boy knew, was going
to Breathitt by that road the next Sunday. How did Crump know
that-how did he know everything? The crevice filled, Crump cut
branches and stuck them between the rocks. Then he pushed his
rifle through the twigs, and taking aim several times, withdrew it.
When he turned away at last and started down to the road, he
looked back once more, and Isom saw him grinning. Almost
chuckling in answer, the lad slipped around the knob to the road
the other way, and Crump threw up his gun with a gasp of fright
when a figure rose out of the dusk before him.
Hol' on, Eli ! " said Isom, easily. " Don't git skeered! Hit's nobody
but me. Whar ye been?"
Crump laughed, so quick was he disarmed of suspicion. " Jes up
the river a piece to see Aunt Sally Day. She's a fust cousin o' mine
Jsom's right hand was slipping back as if to rest on his hip. "D'you
say you'd been 'convicted,' Eli?
Crump's answer was chantlike. "Yes, Lawd reckon I have."
Goin' to stop all o' yer lyin', air ye, ' Isom went on, in the same
tone, and Crump twitched as though struck suddenly from behind,
"an' stealin' 'n' lay-wayin'?"
"Look a-hyeh, boy-" he began, roughly, and mumbling a threat,
Uh, Eli! " Even then the easy voice fooled him again, and he
turned. Isom had a big revolver on a line with his breast. " Drap
yer gun! " he said, tremulously.
Crump tried to laugh, but his guilty face turned gray. "Take keer,
boy," he gasped; "yer gun's cocked. Take keer, I tell ye!
Drap it, damn ye! " Isom called in sudden fury, " 'n' git clean away
from it! " Crump backed, and Isom came forward and stood with
one foot on the fallen Winchester.
"I seed ye, Eli. Been makin' a blind fer Steve, hev ye? Coin' to
shoot him in the back, too, air ye? You're ketched at last, Eli.
You've done a heap o' devilmcnt. You're gittin' wuss all the time.
You oughter be dead, 'n' now-"
Crump found voice in a cry of terror and a whine for mercy. The
boy looked at him, unable to speak his contempt.
"Cit down thar! " he said, finally; and Crump, knowing what was
wanted, stretched himself in the road. Isom sat down on a stone,
the big pistol across one knee.
"Roll over! " Crump rolled at full length.
"Git up! " Isom laughed wickedly. "Ye don't look purty, Eli." He
lifted the pistol and nipped a cake of dirt from the road between
Crump's feet. With another cry of fear, the spy began a vigorous
"Hol' on, Eli; I don't want ye to dance. Ye belong to the chu'ch
now, 'n' I wouldn't have ye go agin yer religion fer nothin'. Stan'
still! Another bullet and another cut between Crump's feet. "Pears
like ye don't think I kin shoot straight. Eli," he went on, reloading
the empty chambers, " some folks think I'm a idgit,
'n' I know 'em. Do you think I'm a idgit, Eli?"
Actin' mighty nateral now." Isom was raising the pistol again. "
Oh, Lawdy! Don't shoot, boy-don't shoot!
"Cit down on yer knees! Now I want ye to beg fer mercy thet ye
never showed-thet ye wouldn't 'a' showed Steve. . . Purty good,"
he said, encouragingly.
Mebbe ye kin pray a leetle, seem' ez ye air a chu'ch member. Pray
fer yer enemies, Eli; Uncl' Gabe says ye must love yer enemies. I
know how ye loves me, 'n' I want yer to pray fer me. The Lawd
mus' sot a powerful store by a good citizen like you. Ax him to
fergive me fer killin' ye."
"Have mercy, O Lawd," prayed Crump, to command-and the
prayer was subtle-" on the murderer of this Thy servant. A life fer a
life, Thou hev said, O Lawd. Fer killin' me he will foller me, 'n' ef
Ye hev not mussy he is boun' fer the lowes' pit o' hell, O Lawd
It was Isom's time to wince now, and Crum p's pious groan was cut
Shet up! " cried the boy, sharply, and he sat a moment silent.
"You've been a-spyin' on us sence I was borned, Eli," he said,
"I believe ye lay-wayed dad. Y'u spied on Rome. Y'u told the
soldiers whar he was a-hidin' Y'u tried to shoot him from the
bresh. Y'u found out Steve was goin' to Breathitt on Sunday, 'n'
you've jes made a blind to shoot him in the back. I reckon thar's no
meanness ye hain't done. Dad's al'ays said ye sot a snare fer a
woman once-a woman! Y'u loaded a musket with slugs, 'n' tied a
string to the trigger, 'n' stretched hit 'cross the path, 'n' y'u got up on
a cliff 'n' whistled to make her slow up jes when she struck the
string. I reckon thet's yer wust-but I don't know."
Several times Crump raised his hands in protest while his
arraignment was going on; several times he tried to speak, but his
lips refused utterance. The boy's voice was getting thicker and
thicker, and he was nervously working the cock of the big pistol up
"Cit up," he said; and Crump rose with a spring. The lad's tone
"You hain't wuth the risk. I hain't goin' ter kill ye. I jus' wanted ter
banter ye 'n' make ye beg. You're a good beggar, Eli, 'n' a powerful
prayer. You'll be a shinin' light in the chu'ch, ef ye gits a chance ter
shine long. Fer lemme tell ye, nobody ever ketched ye afore. But
you're ketched now, an' I'm goin' to tell Steve. He'll be a-watchin'
fer ye, 'n' so 'll I. I tell ye in time, ef ye ever come over hyeh agin
as long as you live, you'll never git back alive. Turn roun'! Hev ye
got any balls? " he asked, feeling in Crump's pockets for cartridges.
" No; well -he picked up the Winchester and pumped the magazine
empty-" I'll keep these," he said, handing Crump the empty rifle.
"Now git away-an' git away quick!
Crump's slouching footsteps went out of hearing, and Isom sat
where he was. His elbows dropped to his knees. His face dropped
slowly into his hands, and the nettles of remorse began to sting.
He took the back of one tremulous hand presently to wipe the
perspiration from his forehead, and he found it burning. A sharp
pain shot through his eyes. He knew what that meant, and feeling
dizzy, he rose and started a little blindly towards home.
Old Gabe was waiting for him. He did not answer the old man's
querulous inquiry, but stumbled towards a bed. An hour later,
when the miller was rubbing his forehead, he opened his eyes, shut
them, and began to talk.
"I reckon I hain't much better 'n Eli, Und' Gabe," he said,
plaintively. "I've been abusin' him down thar in the woods. I come
might' nigh killin' him onct." The old man stroked on, scarcely
heeding the boy's words, so much nonsense would he talk when ill.
I've been lyin' to ye, Unci' Gabe, 'n' a-deceivin' of ye right along.
Steve's a-goin' atter ole Brayton-I'm goin' too-Steve didn't kill
Jass-hit wusn't Steve-hit wusn't Rome-hit was-" The last word
stopped behind his shaking lips; he rose suddenly in bed, looked
wildly into the miller's startled face, and dropping with a sob to the
bed, went sobbing to sleep.
Old Gabe went back to his pipe, and while he smoked, his figure
shrank slowly in his chair. He went to bed finally, but sleep would
not come, and he rose again and built up the fire and sat by it,
waiting for day. His own doctrine, sternly taught for many a year,
had come home to him; and the miller's face when he opened his
door was gray as the breaking light.
THERE was little peace for old Gabe that day at the mill. And
when he went home at night he found cause for the thousand
premonitions that had haunted him. The lad was gone.
A faint light in the east was heralding the moon when Isom
reached Steve Marcum's gate. There were several horses hitched to
the fence, several dim forms seated in the porch, and the lad
halboed for Steve, whose shadow shot instantly from the door and
came towards him.
Glad ter see ye, Isom," he called, jubilantly. I was jus' about to sen'
fer ye. How'd ye happen to come up?"
Isom answered in a low voice with the news of Crump's "blind,"
and Steve laughed and swore in the same breath.
"Come hyeh!" he said, leading the way back; and at the porch he
had Isom tell the story again.
Whut d' I tell ye, boys? " he asked, triumphantly. "Don't believe ye
more 'n half believed me."
Three more horsemen rode up to the gate and came into the light.
Every man was armed, and at Isom's puzzled look, Steve caught
the lad by the arm and led him around the chimney-corner. He
was in high spirits.
"'Pears like ole times, Isom. I'm a-goin' fer thet cussed ole Steve
Brayton this very night. He's behind Crump. I s'picioned it afore;
now I know it for sartain. He's a-goin' to give Eli a mule 'n' a
Winchester fer killin' me. We're goin' to s'prise him to-night. He
won't be look-in' fer us-I've fixed that. I wus jus' about to
sen' fer ye. I hain't fergot how ye kin handle a gun." Steve laughed
significantly. " Ye're a good frien' o' mine, 'n' I'm goin' to show ye
thet I'm a frien' o' yourn."
Isom's paleness was unnoticed in the dark. The old throbbing
began to beat again at his temple; the old haze started from his
"Hyeh's yer gun, Isom," he heard Steve saying next. The fire was
blazing into his face. At the chimney-corner was the bent figure of
old Daddy Marcum, and across his lap shone a Winchester. Steve
was pointing at it, his grim face radiant; the old rnan's toothless
mouth was grinning, and his sharp black eyes were snapping up at
"Hit's yourn, I tell ye," said Steve again. I aimed jes to lend it to ye,
but ye've saved me frum gittin' killed, mebbe, 'n' hit's yourn
now-yourn, boy, fer keeps."
Steve was holding the gun out to him now. The smooth cold touch
of the polished barrel thrilled him. It made everything for an
instant clear again, and feeling weak, Isom sat down on the bed,
gripping the treasure in both trembling hands. On one side of him
some one was repeating Steve's plan of attack. Old Brayton's
cabin was nearly opposite, but they would go up the river, cross
above the mill, and ride back. The night was cloudy, but they
would have the moonlight now and then for the climb up the
mountain. They would creep close, and when the moon was hid
they would run in and get old Brayton alive, if possible. Then-the
rest was with Steve.
Across the room he could hear Steve telling the three new-comers,
with an occasional curse, about Crump's blind, and how he knew
that old Brayton was hiring Crump.
Old Steve's meaner 'n Eli," he said to himself, and a flame of the
old hate surged up from the fire of temptation in his heart. Steve
Marcum was his best friend; Steve had shielded him. The boy had
promised to join him against old Brayton, and here was the
Winchester, brand-new, to bind his word.
"Git ready, boys; git ready."
It was Steve's voice, and in Isom's ears the preacher's voice rang
after it. Again that blinding mist before his eyes, and the boy
brushed at it irritably. He could see the men buckling
cartridge-belts, but he sat still. Two or three men were going out.
Daddy Marcum was leaning on a chair at the door, looking eagerly
at each man as he passed.
Hain't ye goin', Isom?
Somebody was standing before him twirling a rifle on its butt, a
boy near Isom's age. The whirling gun made him dizzy.
Stop it! " he cried, angrily. Old Daddy Marcum was answering the
boy's question from the door.
"Isom goin'?" he piped, proudly. "I reckon he air. Whar's yer belt,
boy? Git ready. Git ready."
Isom rose then-he could not answer sitting down-and caught at a
bedpost with one hand, while he fumbled at his throat with the
"I hain't goin'."
Steve heard at the door, and whirled around. Daddy Marcum was
tottering across the floor, with one bony hand uplifted.
"You're a coward! " The name stilled every sound. Isom, with eyes
afire, sprang at the old man to strike, but somebody caught his arm
and forced him back to the bed.
"Shet up, dad," said Steve, angrily, looking sharply into Isom's
face. " Don't ye see the boy's sick? He needn't go ef he don't want
to. Time to start, boys."
The tramp of heavy boots started across the puncheon floor and
porch again. Isom could hear Steve's orders outside; the laughs
and jeers and curses of the men as they mounted their horses; he
heard the cavalcade pass through the gate, the old man's cackling
good-by; then the horses' hoofs going down the mountain, and
Daddy Marcum's hobbling step on the porch again. He was
standing in the middle of the floor, full in the firelight, when the
old man reached the threshold-standing in a trance, with a
cartridge-belt in his hand.
"Good fer you, Isom
The cry was apologetic, and stopped short.
The critter's fersakcn," he quavered, and cowed by the boy's
strange look, the old man shrank away from him along the wall.
But Isom seemed neither to see nor hear. He caught up his rifle,
and, wavering an instant, tossed it with the belt on the bed and ran
out the door. The old man followed, dumb with amazement.
Isom! " he called, getting his wits and his tongue at last. "Hyeh's
yer gun! Come back, I tell ye! You've fergot yer gun! Isom! Isom!
The voice piped shrilly out into the darkness, and piped back
A steep path, dangerous even by day, ran snakelike from the cabin
down to the water's edge. It was called Isom's path after that tragic
night. No mountaineer went down it thereafter without a firm
faith that only by the direct help of Heaven could the boy, in his
flight down through the dark, have reached the river and the other
side alive. The path dropped from ledge to ledge, and ran the
brink of precipices and chasms. In a dozen places the boy crashed
through the undergrowth from one slippery fold to the next below,
catching at roots and stones, slipping past death a score of times,
and dropping on till a flood of yellow light lashed the gloom
before him. Just there the river was most narrow; the nose of a
cliff swerved the current sharply across, and on the other side an
eddy ran from it up stream. These earthly helps he had, and he
There had been a rain-storm, and the waves swept him away like
thistle-down, and beat back at him as he fought through them and
stood choked and panting on the other shore. He did not dare stop
to rest. The Marcums, too, had crossed the river up at the ford by
this time, and were galloping towards him; and Isom started on
and up. When he reached the first bench of the spur the moon was
swinging over Thunderstruck Knob. The clouds broke as he
clinibed; strips of radiant sky showed between the rolling masses,
and the mountain above was light and dark in quick succession.
He had no breath when he reached the ledge that ran below old
Steve's cabin, and flinging one arm above it, he fell through sheer
exhaustion. The cabin was dark as the clump of firs behind it; the
inmates were unsuspecting; and Steve Marcum and his men were
not far below. A rumbling started under him, while he lay there
and grew faint-the rumble of a stone knocked from the path by a
horse's hoof. Isom tried to halbo, but his voice stopped in a
whisper, and he painfully drew himself upon the rock, upright
under the bright moon. A quick oath of warning came then-it was
Crump's shrill voice in the Brayton cabin-and Isom stumbled
forward with both hands thrown up and a gasping cry at his lips.
One flash came through a port-hole of the cabin. A yell broke on
the night-Crump's cry again-and the boy swayed across the rock,
and falling at the brink, dropped with a limp struggle out of sight.
THE news of Isom's fate reached the miller by way of Hazlan
before the next noon. Several men in the Brayton cabin had
recognized the boy in the moonlight. At daybreak they found
bloodstains on the ledge and on a narrow shelf a few feet farther
down. Isom had slipped from one to the other, they said, and in
his last struggle had rolled over into Dead Creek, and had been
swept into the Cumberland.
It was Crump who had warned the Braytons. Nobody ever knew
how he had learned Steve Marcum's purpose. And old Brayton on
his guard and in his own cabin was impregnable. So the Marcums,
after a harmless fusillade, had turned back cursing. Mocking
shouts followed after them, pistol-shots, even the scraping of a
fiddle and shuffling on the ledge. But they kept on, cursing across
the river and back to Daddy Marcum, who was standing in the
porch, peermg for them through the dawn, with a story to tell
" The critter was teched in the head," the old man said, and this
was what the Braytons, too, believed. But Steve Marcum, going to
search for Isom's body next day, gave old Gabe another theory. He
told the miller how Daddy Marcum had called Isom a coward, and
Steve said the boy had gone ahead to prove he was no coward.
"He had mighty leetle call to prove it to me. Think o' his takin' ole
Brayton all by hisself! he said, with a look at the yellow, heaving
Cumberland. "'N', Lord! think o' his swimmin' that river in the
Old Gabe asked a question fiercely then and demanded the truth,
and Steve told him about the hand-to-hand fight on the
mountain-side, about young Jasper's treachery, and how the boy,
who was watching the fight, fired just in time to save Rome. It
made all plain at last-Rome's and Steve's denials, Isom's dinning
on that one theme,' and why the boy could not go to Rome and face
Martha, with her own blood on his hands. Isom's true motive, too,
was plain, and the miller told it brokenly to Steve, who rode away
with a low whistle to tell it broadcast, and left the old man rocking
his body like a woman.
An hour later he rode back at a gallop to tell old Gabe to search the
river bank below the mill. He did not believe Isom dead. It was
just his feelin'," he said, and one fact, that nobody else thought
important - the Brayton canoe was gone.
Ef he was jus' scamped by a ball," said Steve, "you kin bet he tuk
the boat, 'n' he's down thar in the bushes somewhar now waitin' fer
And about dusk, sure enough, old Gabe, wandering hopefully
through the thicket below the mill, stumbled over the canoe
stranded in the bushes. In the new mud were the tracks of a boy's
bare feet leading into the thicket, and the miller made straight for
home. When he opened his door he began to shake as if with palsy.
A figure was seated on the hearth against the chimney, and the
firelight was playing over the face and hair. The lips were parted,
and the head hung limply to the breast. The clothes were torn to
rags, and one shoulder was bare. Through the upper flesh of it and
close to the nrck was an ugly burrow clotted with blood. The boy
Three nights later, in Hazlan, Sherd Raines told the people of
Isom's flight down the mountain, across the river, and up the steep
to save his life by losing it. Before he was done, one gray-headed
figure pressed from the darkness on one side and stood trembling
under the dips. It was old Steve Brayton, who had fired from the
cabin at Isom, and dropping his Winchester, he stumbled forward
with the butt of his pistol held out to Raines. A Marcum appeared
on the other side with the muzzle of his Winchester down. Raines
raised both hands then and imperiously called on every man who
had a weapon to come forward and give it up. Like children they
came, Marcums and Braytons, piling their arms on the rock before
him, shaking hands right and left, and sitting together on the
Old Brayton was humbled thereafter. He wanted to shake hands
with Steve Marcum and make friends. But Steve grinned, and
said, "Not yit," and went off into the bushes. A few days later he
went to Hazlan of his own accord and gave up his gun to Raines.
He wouldn't shake hands with old Brayton, he said, nor with any
other man who would hire another man to do his "killin';" but he
promised to fight no more, and he kept his word.
A flood followed on New Year's day. Old Gabe's canoe-his
second canoe-was gone, and a Marcum and a Brayton worked side
by side at the mill hollowing out another. The miller sat at the
"'Pears like folks is havin' bad luck with thar dugouts." said
Brayton. "Some trifin' cuss took old Steve Brayton's jes to cross
the river, without the grace to tie it to the bank, let 'lone takin' it
back. I've heard ez how Aunt Sally Day's boy Ben, who was
a-fishin' that evenin, says ez how he seed Isom's harnt a-floatin'
across the river in it, without techin' a paddle."
The Marcum laughed. "Idgits is thick over hyeh," he said. " Ben's
a-gittin' wuss sence Isom was killed. Yes, I recollect Gabe hyeh
lost a canoe jus' atter a flood more'n a year ago, when Rome
Stetson 'n' Marthy Lewallen went a-gallivantin' out' n the
mountains together. Hyeh's another flood, 'n' old Gabe's dugout
gone agin." The miller raised a covert glance of suspicion from
under his hat, but the Marcum was laughing. "Ye oughter put a
trace-chain on this un," he added. "A rope gits rotten in the water,
'n' a tide is mighty apt to break it."
Old Gabe said that "mebbe that wus so," but he had no chain to
waste; he reckoned a rope was strong enough, and he started home.
"Old Gabe don't seem to keer much now 'bout Isom," said the
Brayton. " Folks say he tuk on so awful at fust that hit looked like
he wus goin' crazy. He's gittin' downright peert again. Hello!
Bud Vickers was carrying a piece of news down to Hazlan, and he
pulled up his horse to deliver it. Aunt Sally Day's dog had been
seen playing in the Breathitt road with the frame of a human foot.
Some boys had found not far away, behind a withered" blind," a
heap of rags and bones. Eli Crump had not been seen in Hazlan
since the night of the Marcum raid.
Well, ef hit was Eli," said the Brayton, waggishly, "we're all goin'
to be saved. Eli's case 'll come fust, an' ef thar's only one
Jedgment Day, the Lord 'll nuver git to us."
The three chuckled, while old Gabe sat dreammg at his gate. The
boy had lain quiet during the weeks of his getting well, absorbed in
one aim-to keep hidden until he was strong enough to get to Rome.
On the last night the miller had raised one of the old hearth-stones
and had given him the hire of many years. At daybreak the lad
drifted away. Now old Gabe was following him down the river
and on to the dim mountain line, where the boy's figure was plain
for a moment against the sky, and then was lost.
The clouds in the west had turned gray and the crescent had
broken the gloom of the woods into shadows when the miller rose.
One star was coming over Black Mountain from the east. It was
the Star of Bethlehem to old Gabe; and, starlike on both sides of
the Cumberland, answering fires from cabin hearths were giving
back its message at last.
"Thar hain't nothin' to hender Rome 'n' Marthy now. I nuver
knowed anybody to stay 'way from these mount'ins ef he could git
back; 'n' Isom said he'd fetch 'em. Thar hain't notliin' to hender
On the stoop of the cabin the miller turned to look again, and then
on the last Stetson the door was closed.